what we do
Custom cookies.
With cookies that taste as delicious as they look, make every one of life’s sweetest occasions even more memorable.
Every cookie is baked fresh, iced by hand, and thoughtfully designed for your celebration. We use a classic buttery, vanilla sugar cookie recipe and finish each one with smooth royal icing, custom colors, and detailed designs.
Specialties
Corporate orders.
Custom orders.
Pricing
Decorated cookies start at $5.00 per cookie with a minimum order of 1 dozen ($60). Cookies with metallic-painted accents cost an additional 50 cents per cookie. Orders must be placed at least 2 weeks in advance.
If you would like something different that isn’t shown on the website, please reach out for a custom quote.
What people are saying.
“The cookies were a HUGE hit. I had people tracking me down for them. Everyone was in awe, and asked about my source!… Honestly, the best cookie I’ve tasted.”
— Teri B.
“As usual, you out did yourself. The cookies are fabulous!!!”
— Joanne C.
“Your cupcakes and cookies were of course a hit!!!! And several people picked up your card :) Love your talent and creativity!!!”
— Jenny V.
Interested?
Send us an email.
Recent projects.
Butterscotch Bakery
Butterscotch Bakery has been sweetening life’s moments for over five years with our exquisite custom-decorated cookies. From bridal showers and baby showers to birthdays and corporate events, our treats promise to dazzle and delight.
Send us an email to find out how to make your next occasion extraordinary!
Disclaimer
Products are produced under cottage food law in a home kitchen not subject to state licensing or inspection. Made in a pet-free, smoke-free home.
Sales are restricted to Wisconsin residents. We primarily serve the Lake Country area, including Delafield, Pewaukee, Oconomowoc, and Hartland, as well as other communities in southeastern Wisconsin including Brookfield, Elm Grove, and more.
Contact info
info@butterscotch-bakery.com
Delafield, Wisconsin
